The rugby world is buzzing after the Springboks' recent match against Italy, where they deployed some eyebrow-raising tactics. New Zealand's head coach, Scott Robertson, has described South Africa's approach as "unique" and "innovative," sparking debate and discussion across the sport.
Unconventional Moves Raise Eyebrows
South Africa surprised everyone right from the kickoff. Andre Esterhuizen deliberately collected Manie Libbok's chip kick while in an offside position, before the ball traveled ten meters. This resulted in a scrum awarded to Italy. But the Springboks didn't stop there. They twice set up a maul in open play, lifting a player as if they were at a line-out. This tactic proved successful, leading to tries on both occasions. The Boks dominated Italy, securing a 45-0 victory despite an early red card for Jasper Wiese.
Divided Opinions on Legality
These tactics have sparked considerable debate. Some question whether these moves are within the laws of the game. However, All Blacks coach Robertson praised the Springboks' innovative approach. "It’s pretty unique, isn’t it? We’re talking about it, it’s great for our game," he said. He also noted that World Rugby will likely review the tactics and decide whether to allow them or change the rules.
Robertson pointed out that rugby has "laws, not rules," which can sometimes lead to interpretation. He even shared an anecdote from his time playing for Perpignan, where they used a similar kick-off routine.
All Blacks Legend Slams Springboks Performance
Despite the win and innovative tactics, All Blacks legend John Kirwan criticized the Springboks' overall performance. Speaking on The Rivals podcast, Kirwan admitted enjoying the tactics but called the display "the worst and most frustrating performance I’ve seen from South Africa in a long time."
Kirwan, who coached Italy in the early 2000s, appreciated the opening kick-off tactic, recalling a similar attempt by his Italian team that resulted in a penalty. He emphasized the need to understand the line between innovation and flaunting the laws.
Kirwan believes that teams like France and New Zealand will have learned a lot from the match. He suggested that some of the Springboks players weren't performing at the level expected. "You’re always looking for a fault or a way to beat the world champions," he said.