The future of Nolan Arenado with the St. Louis Cardinals is uncertain, sparking speculation about a potential trade or release. After an orchestrated moment to honor Arenado at Busch Stadium, and with a new front office taking over, the Cardinals are considering their options for the ten-time Gold Glove winner.
Arenado's Sentiments and the Cardinals' Plans
Arenado himself has expressed a sense that his time with the Cardinals might be coming to an end. The Cardinals, motivated to trim payroll and open up an infield spot for younger players, are reportedly considering trading Arenado for the second consecutive offseason. Chaim Bloom, the new president of baseball operations, will play a key role in deciding Arenado's fate.
Potential Replacements at Third Base
If Arenado departs, the Cardinals will need to fill the void at third base. Internal options include Nolan Gorman, Thomas Saggese, and Jose Fermin, who all saw playing time at third base due to Arenado's injury. The Cardinals could also explore acquiring a player for a low cost to temporarily fill the position while the team rebuilds.
Arenado's Performance and Contract
Arenado's 2025 season was considered a down year, but he remained the team's primary third baseman when healthy. He is currently under contract for the next two seasons, with $32 million remaining on his deal. The Cardinals previously attempted to trade Arenado last offseason, even agreeing to a deal with the Astros, but Arenado exercised his right to veto the trade.
With the Cardinals in a transition phase, focused on getting younger, the team might opt to release Arenado and absorb the remaining salary. This would allow Arenado to choose his next destination.
A Farewell to St. Louis?
Sunday's game against the Brewers could very well be Arenado's final home game as a Cardinal. The team made a late lineup change to ensure Arenado received an ovation from the home fans. Only time will tell what the future holds for Arenado and the Cardinals.